Tyler's Homemade Ice Cream

Tyler's Homemade Ice Cream serves the Cortez, Bradenton, and Longboat Key communities from three Florida locations, earning a 4.7-star rating across more than 1,100 customer reviews. This family-friendly ice cream shop specializes in hand-dipped pints and quarts, soft-serve treats, and elaborate sundaes made fresh on premise. Open Monday through Sunday with weekday hours starting at 1 PM and weekend hours extending from noon, the shop accommodates both quick stops and leisurely visits after beach outings.

What distinguishes Tyler'S is their commitment to generous portions and made-from-scratch recipes. The menu features hard ice cream in rotating flavors, custom-build-your-own sundaes, banana splits, milkshakes, and floats. Staff consistently offer samples so customers can explore unfamiliar flavors before committing. The Bradenton location at Manatee Avenue and the original Cortez storefront both maintain a Mom-and-Pop atmosphere where visitors receive personalized attention with their orders.

Reviewers repeatedly highlight specific menu items that draw them back. The peanut butter sundae earns particular praise, with one reviewer calling it the best she has ever had. Beach-goers from Longboat Key make the shop a routine stop on their way back from the shore. Multiple reviewers note sundaes so substantial they skipped dinner afterward, while others appreciate the variety of hard ice cream flavors that change with the seasons.