14 AC Repair Contractors in Shelbyville, IN

4.8 avg rating
955 total reviews5 offer 24/7 service
Need emergency service? 5 HVAC providers in Shelbyville offer 24/7 availability

Top-Rated AC Repair Contractors in Shelbyville

#1

Quality Comfort Heating and Air LLC

5.0(301 reviews)
Highly Rated

Every one of the 301 reviews carries a 5-star rating, with Andrew named in multiple reviews as the primary contact for installations. Four separate reviews…

5557 N Morristown Rd, Shelbyville, IN 46176
#2

Pierce-Tucker Heating Cooling and Plumbing

5.0(233 reviews)
24/7 Highly Rated

All five sampled reviewers award 5-star ratings. Four of five mention specific technicians (Josh, Douglas) by name and comment on repair outcomes. Three…

1117 St Joseph St, Shelbyville, IN 46176
#3

Hicks Air LLC

4.9(75 reviews)
24/7

Six verified reviewers cite emergency responsiveness and same-day service. Multiple customers explicitly praise honest diagnostics over upselling, with three…

705 S Noble St, Shelbyville, IN 46176

All AC Repair Contractors (14 total)

True Air Heating & Cooling

4.9(73)

Seventy-three reviews yield a perfect 5-star average rating, with seven verified customers providing detailed…

46 E Washington St, Shelbyville, IN 46176

Christian Electric, LLC

4.4(83)

Five of six detailed reviews award five stars, praising same-day response times, fair pricing, and…

318 E Broadway St, Shelbyville, IN 46176

Raymoore Heating and Cooling LLC.

4.8(44)
24/7

All forty-four reviews carry five-star ratings, with seven reviewers specifically naming technicians Travis,…

1237 Jefferson Ave, Shelbyville, IN 46176

People's Heating & Cooling

4.8(37)
24/7

Thirty-seven reviews aggregate to a 4.8-star average, with every reviewer awarding 5 stars. Multiple accounts…

1310 Jefferson Ave, Shelbyville, IN 46176

Sears Appliance Repair

4.2(52)

Mixed sentiment appears across 52 reviews, with several negative experiences citing extended service windows…

510 Saraina Rd, Shelbyville, IN 46176

Tuck's Radiator & Air Conditioning Services

4.4(33)

Four positive reviews highlight honest pricing and skilled repairs, while three critical reviews cite quote…

807 Miller Ave, Shelbyville, IN 46176

Shelby Mechanical

5.0(10)

All five accessible reviews award five stars, with three specifically mentioning pricing transparency and…

4526 N 500 E, Shelbyville, IN 46176

Scott Cook Heating and Cooling

5.0(5)

All 5 reviews award 5 stars, with 1 verified reviewer documenting same-day arrival under acute heat…

1822 E McKay Rd, Shelbyville, IN 46176

Drake's Supply

5.0(4)

All 4 reviews award 5 stars, with client language citing 'fantastic' and 'good' experienced staff members.…

1310 Jefferson Ave, Shelbyville, IN 46176

Turnkey Mechanical and Electrical Corporation.

4.3(3)
24/7

1 reviewer expressed uncertainty about whether the business remained active, citing communication…

1315 Hale Rd, Shelbyville, IN 46176

C&S Home solutions LLC

5.0(2)

Two clients award perfect 5-star ratings, with one reviewer specifically citing professional conduct and…

339 E Pennsylvania St, Shelbyville, IN 46176

AC Repair Costs in Shelbyville

Typical repair costs for Shelbyville homeowners, by problem type.

ServiceLowAverageHigh
Diagnostic / service call
Usually credited toward repair
$83$132$220
Refrigerant recharge (R-410A)
$165$385$770
Capacitor replacement
$132$275$495
Fan motor replacement
$275$495$770
Compressor replacement
$880$1,980$3,080
Evaporator coil repair
$440$990$1,650
Labor (hourly rate)
Per hour during business hours
$83$121$165

Prices reflect continental metro averages compiled from published industry cost guides, contractor surveys, and regional labor data. Last updated: April 2026.

AC Repair in Shelbyville, IN: What to Expect

Shelbyville sits within the Indianapolis metro area, where humid summers push daytime highs into the mid-80s and create genuine strain on residential cooling systems. Though cold winters averaging 21 F from November through March keep heating equipment running constantly, summer humidity and heat waves drive consistent demand for AC Repair in Shelbyville. Fourteen contractors compete for business here, holding an average rating of 4.8 across 955 client reviews, a market where dependable service translates directly to homeowner loyalty during peak summer months.

Homeowners calling for service typically encounter a diagnostic fee ranging from $83 to $220 per visit. More extensive work, such as refrigerant recharge using R-410A, costs between $165 and $770, while capacitor replacement runs $132 to $495 depending on part availability and labor time. Indiana does not require a statewide HVAC license, so local municipal requirements apply and contractors must maintain proper credentials within their respective jurisdictions to operate legally.

Customer feedback highlights clear differences among top performers. Quality Comfort Heating and Air LLC maintains all 301 reviews at 5 stars, with Andrew mentioned repeatedly for efficient installations completed on tight timelines. Pierce-Tucker Heating Cooling and Plumbing also holds a 5-star average, with technicians Josh and Douglas named by satisfied clients who specifically note fair pricing alongside reliable repairs. Hicks Air, rated 4.9, draws particular praise for emergency responsiveness and honest diagnostics that focus on actual fixes rather than unnecessary upselling.

Frequently Asked Questions

AC repair in Shelbyville typically costs $83-$3,080 depending on the problem. Diagnostic calls run around $75-$200, refrigerant recharges $150-$700, capacitor replacement $120-$450, and compressor replacement $800-$2,800. Most contractors apply the diagnostic fee toward the final repair cost if you proceed.