Surf Club At Montauk

Surf Club Montauk occupies a prime beachfront position on Surfside Avenue in Montauk, New York, earning 4.3 stars across 256 reviews. This East End resort offers one- and two-bedroom beach-side bungalows with duplex configurations, catering to weekend travelers and extended stays alike. The property features an outdoor swimming pool, fitness center, and concierge services, positioning itself as a home away from home for visitors seeking authentic Montauk experiences. Managed professionally by Ocean Bay Management, Inc., the resort serves guests traveling from across Long Island and the broader New York metropolitan area.

The property distinguishes itself through its wellness programming, hosting morning yoga and pilates sessions throughout the summer months. Guests can enjoy outdoor movie nights and food truck events during July and August, creating family-friendly entertainment steps from the sand. The resort offers beach chairs and umbrella service, with the Montauk village restaurants and shops accessible within a short two-block walk. Accommodations feature contemporary design blended with timeless Montauk style, complete with high-speed Wi-Fi access and plush bedding in each suite.

Reviewer experiences reveal mixed service quality. Skygazer praised unit 12 as very nice, noting fresh bathroom renovations and friendly staff, with the Montauk Bakery highlighted nearby. However, multiple reviewers documented significant concerns: ErikJ415 reported mold stench requiring three clothing washes and described damp, mildew-laden floors with filthy air conditioning units. Timothy Karniewich and 370love both criticized the property as overpriced for three-star quality, with 370love noting a rotten sewage smell. WeloveCarib cited inconsistent housekeeping, unmotivated front desk management, and housekeeping staff using the gym equipment meant for guests. The recurring complaint centers on premium pricing failing to match operational standards.