Smucker Propane LLC

Smucker Propane LLC supplies propane to homeowners across Gap, Pennsylvania and surrounding Lancaster County communities. The company maintains a 4.0-star rating drawn from 10 customer reviews, operating Monday through Friday from 8 AM to 5 PM. Customers reach the office directly at (717) 768-7427. Reviewers note the company serves both owned-tank and company-owned tank customers, with delivery available to residential communities including Holtwood and surrounding 55+ retirement neighborhoods.

Multiple five-star reviewers highlight competitive pricing as a primary differentiator, noting Smucker Propane consistently undercuts competitors in the region. Linda Watkins specifically mentions the company's Fuel Good Initiative as part of her positive experience. The combination of lower wholesale pricing and straightforward service terms appeals to budget-conscious homeowners comparing propane vendors across southern Pennsylvania.

Customer experiences reveal mixed service quality. Linda Watkins and Jenny L praise prompt same-day delivery and courteous drivers, with Jenny specifically calling out careful handling during drop-offs. Esther Stoltzfus notes quick response times, characterizing the service as faster than competing providers. However, two one-star reviews from Candie Brey and Charlyn Maldonado cite communication breakdowns, unexpected surcharges, and perceived dismissiveness during service disputes, concerns worth weighng against the majority positive feedback.