Wolgemuth Auction

Wolgemuth Auction operates as a well-established auction house in Lancaster County, Pennsylvania, with a 4.2-star rating drawn from 164 customer reviews. Located in Leola, the business hosts regular sales at two venues: their primary Leola facility and a New Holland location for hay auctions. Since 1955, the company has facilitated transactions across equipment, lumber, hay, and off-site auction categories. The team maintains standard weekday hours Monday through Friday from 7:30 AM to 4:30 PM, with Saturday morning sales rotating between locations.

What distinguishes Wolgemuth is their specialized auction calendar built around agricultural and construction equipment, hay and straw, and lumber and building materials. Their Hay Report Dashboard represents a recent innovation for tracking market values. Monthly equipment auctions draw tractors, skid steers, and excavators, while hay sales occur bi-weekly at both Leola and New Holland venues. Lumber auctions run every second Thursday, offering surplus building materials to contractors and homeowners alike. For sellers seeking turnkey solutions, off-site auctions conduct complete sales directly on the property.

Customer experiences reveal both strengths and friction points. Reviewers consistently praise the office staff and load-out crew for helpfulness during pickup. One five-star reviewer noted they have both sold and purchased through the service. However, negative reviews cite concerns: a 2024 reviewer alleged shill bidding on equipment, another complained about credit card fees for internet bidding, and a recent buyer described a machine failing within minutes of transport. These accounts suggest potential variability in item quality and communication around payment policies.