23 HVAC Repair Contractors in Columbus, IN
Top-Rated HVAC Repair Contractors in Columbus
Greenwell Plumbing Heating & Air
“Six of six detailed reviews award 5 stars, with technicians named individually (Gavin, Tyler, Jaz) each receiving specific praise for diagnostic skill and…”
Peterman Brothers Heating Cooling Plumbing
“Every one of the sampled reviews awards five stars, with customers frequently using terms like knowledgeable, professional, and personable. Technicians named…”
All HVAC Repair Contractors (23 total)
Summers Plumbing Heating & Cooling
“Positive reviews frequently mention quick scheduling and same-day repairs, while negative reviews cite…”
Advantage Heating and Air Conditioning Repair
“Nearly nine hundred reviews averaging 4.9 stars reflect consistency across hundreds of service calls. Two…”
Johnson Heating, Cooling, and Plumbing
“467 reviews yield a 4.9 average rating, with named technicians Tyree, Jake, Nick, and Jesse appearing across…”
Star Heating & Air
“421 reviews produce a perfect 5.0-star average, with Jason named across every detailed testimonial as the…”
Dugan Air Heating & Cooling
“Fourteen of twenty-five sampled reviewers specifically reference timely arrivals during emergency calls, with…”
Call Joe
“All five reviewers awarded five stars, with four specifically praising Joe's diagnostic clarity and the…”
Loesch Heating & Air Conditioning, LLC
“Every reviewer awarded five stars, describing thorough inspections, same-day emergency response during…”
Peters' Heating and Air Conditioning
“Four of five detailed reviews praise same-day or rapid-response service, with three specifically mentioning…”
Total Comfort Heating & Air
“All nineteen reviews carry five stars, with technicians Mark, Bryan, and Brian Blankenhorn mentioned by name…”
Service My Restaurants
“Three of seven reviewers award five stars, praising specific technicians and thorough work. Three reviewers…”
Mission Air
“Seven reviewers grant perfect scores, with four specifically praising responsive same-day or next-morning…”
Goodner
“Six of seven reviewers awarded five-star ratings while specifically praising either diagnostic…”
Tacti-Cool Air LLC
“All five reviewers awarded five stars, with four specifically mentioning Eric by name as the technician who…”
L&J Heating and Air
“All five reviews award five stars, with three specifically naming Tim as the technician providingservice.…”
Accuracy Mechanical
“Both clients awarded five stars, with Austin receiving direct mentions in each review. Customers describe the…”
Smith Brothers Precision Air Systems
“One of three reviewers awarded five stars specifically praising technician Steve's responsiveness, diagnostic…”
Southern Comfort Solutions
“One client scored the experience five stars, calling the team highly skilled with competitive rates and…”
Ireland HVAC Columbus
“One of two reviews gives five stars with vague praise, while the other assigns one star and accuses the…”
HVAC Repair Costs in Columbus
Typical heating and cooling repair costs in Columbus, by component.
| Service | Low | Average | High |
|---|---|---|---|
Diagnostic / service call | $83 | $132 | $220 |
Thermostat replacement | $165 | $303 | $550 |
Blower motor replacement | $440 | $715 | $1,210 |
Heat exchanger replacement | $1,650 | $2,420 | $3,850 |
Ignitor replacement (gas furnace) | $165 | $275 | $440 |
Control board replacement | $330 | $605 | $990 |
Full system repair (major) Multi-component failure | $550 | $1,320 | $3,300 |
Prices reflect continental metro averages compiled from published industry cost guides, contractor surveys, and regional labor data. Last updated: April 2026.
HVAC Repair in Columbus, IN: What to Expect
Living in Bartholomew County means dealing with swings that would exhaust most systems. Columbus sees summer highs pushing toward 86 F with roughly three weeks of temperatures crossing the 90-degree mark, paired with the kind of humidity that makes your air conditioner work overtime from June well into August. Winters settle around 21 F, and the heating season stretches from November through March, which creates persistent demand for qualified help. With seventeen HVAC contractors serving the Columbus market and an average rating of 4.1 across more than forty-five hundred reviews, residents have plenty of options but often struggle to separate the consistent performers from those who vanish after the first call.
Understanding what you might pay removes some of the guesswork from an already stressful situation. A diagnostic or service call in Columbus typically runs between $83 and $220, while thermostat replacement generally falls in the $165 to $550 range. Blower motor replacement, which involves more labor and parts, usually costs between $440 and $1,210. These figures represent the broad market, so actual invoices depend on the specific equipment, the complexity of the diagnosis, and the individual contractor's approach to pricing. Indiana does not require a statewide HVAC license, which means local licensing standards vary, and verifying a company's standing with Bartholomew County regulators before agreeing to work makes practical sense.
The feedback left by Columbus homeowners points to clear differences in how these companies operate. Peterman Brothers draws consistent praise for technicians like David and John, with customers repeatedly describing their work as knowledgeable, professional, and personable. Advantage Heating and Air Conditioning Repair holds a 4.9 average across nearly nine hundred reviews, and technicians Derek and Raymond appear so frequently in five-star accounts that they have become part of the company's reputation. Summers Plumbing Heating & Cooling earns credit for quick scheduling and same-day repairs, though some customers note installation complications and longer waits for certain issues to be fully resolved. This pattern suggests that matching your needs to a company's strengths, whether that is rapid response or meticulous installation, matters more than chasing the highest rating alone.
Frequently Asked Questions
Other HVAC Services in Columbus, IN
All HVAC Contractors in Columbus, IN
Complete directory of 31 contractors — browse alphabetically
A–Z
All HVAC Contractors in Columbus, IN
Complete directory of 31 contractors — browse alphabetically