Casey's

Casey's at 1651 Meadowlark Lane in Excelsior Springs operates as a 24-hour convenience store serving the local community and travelers along Highway 69. With 189 Google reviews yielding a 3.4-star average, the store functions as a combination fuel station and prepared-food counter. The Excelsior Springs location is one of several Casey's stores throughout western Missouri, offering gasoline, automotive supplies, and a hot food menu centered on baked pizzas and packaged snacks.

The prepared-food counter represents this location's distinguishing feature, with made-to-order pizzas baked onsite drawing consistent customer attention. Unlike typical gas station food stops, the Excelsior Springs Casey's features a visible pizza preparation area where staff members assemble and cook custom pies throughout the day. Customers can request specific toppings and watch their order come together, which several reviewers identify as a cut above standard convenience dining.

Reviewer Brian Endsley recounted a recent visit praising employee Tammy by name, noting she assembled a birthday pizza with extra cheese and took time to resolve an automated order-system failure. Conversely, reviewer Shawn Beckwith documented a December 2024 experience involving a 40-minute hold time after receiving an incorrect jalape o popper pizza instead of the pepperoni variety ordered. The negative review criticized wait times and communication, contrasting sharply with the positive sentiment directed at staff who engage directly with customers.