Metalico Buffalo

Metalico Buffalo operates as a scrap metal recycling facility serving the greater Buffalo metropolitan area, including Niagara Falls, with multiple collection points throughout Western New York. The company maintains a 4.2-star rating derived from 94 customer reviews, reflecting a customer base that spans residential homeowners, automotive businesses, and industrial operations. Located at 127 Fillmore Ave in Buffalo's industrial corridor, Metalico Buffalo positions itself as a full-service recycler accepting ferrous and non-ferrous metals, with additional locations in Niagara Falls and two other Buffalo sites.

The business distinguishes itself through a VIP Rewards Club program that offers points for every pound of scrap recycled, redeemable for future transactions. Metalico provides container services ranging from small bins to large roll-off containers, accommodating projects of varying scale from residential cleanouts to commercial demolition. Their online pricing tool allows customers to check current market rates before visiting, and they market themselves on transparency and competitive payouts. The company accepts automotive parts, industrial metals, electrical components, and construction debris, positioning as a one-stop recycling destination.

Reviewers cite specific experiences with the staff at Metalico, with Dominic Justus noting the front office team as 'super nice' and describing six to seven months of reliable service. Jay M. specifically mentions 'best prices around town' while Dennis McGeary highlights office personnel who helped him complete a transaction 'in and out in no time.' John G. reports twenty-five years of continued business with the company, praising their honesty. Negative feedback centers on operational inconsistencies, with one reviewer documenting a closure despite posted hours and another citing an early 3:45 p.m. closure when 4 p.m. was advertised.