Carr Supply - Dayton

Carr Supply in Dayton, Ohio has served the local plumbing industry for decades as a professional supply house, currently holding a 4.2-star rating from 48 customer reviews. Located at 2312 Whipp Road, the store operates as a contractor-focused distribution center while also accommodating homeowners who call ahead. The business serves the greater Dayton metropolitan area including Kettering, Beavercreek, and Miamisburg, maintaining weekday hours from 7 AM to 4:30 PM Monday through Friday. While primarily designed for licensed plumbing and HVAC professionals, the counter staff assists walk-in customers when inventory permits.

What distinguishes Carr Supply is its dual model: a professional counter service for regular contractors alongside an appointment-only showroom for high-end kitchen and bath remodeling projects. The store stocks major plumbing fixture lines and carries HVAC-adjacent components, with staff like Joe Cheatwood noting they helped troubleshoot an unusual HVAC situation for a remodeling contractor. Evan Schreck, who visits multiple times weekly, describes the counter team as awesome and friendly, while Eric Kreitzer found what he needed even without contractor credentials, though he noted prices ran approximately $75 higher than online options for the same item.

Customer experiences vary based on customer type. Joe Cheatwood, a remodeling contractor, received extremely patient help resolving an unusual HVAC-related puzzle. Eric Kreitzer, though not a professional, successfully picked up a needed item same-day with checkout handled smoothly at the front desk. However, Bill Baglio, a homeowner from Bellbrook, was turned away from the showroom without an appointment, while another reviewer described an initial rude greeting. The positive reviews consistently praise counter staff by name, while negative feedback targets the appointment-only showroom policy not being clear to casual visitors.